ʻO wai lā ka mea he anarchist a me ka mea ana i makemake?

Ka iwakalua kenekulia i ke au o ka hooulu ana mai o nā pilina theories, ka haʻiʻana i ka makemake o ka noʻonoʻo hoa o ke kaiāulu no ka hoʻoikaika 'ana i ka nohona pili. E like me ka hapanui poe akeakamai, Artists, a me kekahi manawa ano o townsfolk, ua hele mai manaʻo kanaka i ka hopena make o ka noho maikai ana, i ka auoiaea o i ho kekahi poe noonoo ole, a me ka kekahi - aneane hiki ole i.

Ka hapanui o thinkers ia mau lā i ka pili aloha ma waena lālā hoʻi o ke kaiāulu, ka nānā 'anaʻano nui ma compulsion a me ka mea pono, e alakai ana i ka degeneration o ke kanaka lāhui. Inhibition o kekahi Hoʻohana 'ē aʻe o ka heluna kanaka, e lawe wahi like loa me ka moku'āina i koe, a me ka hana mea inevitable ma na olelo o ka huakūʻai-dala ana, - i ka poe ma ka kūpaʻa Social Democrats a me ka Marxists.

Ma ka huli ana o ke kenekulia ua lilo i mea mahaloia loa paradoxical a me ka'ano'ē manaʻo, i pau ka poe i hea aku ai no ka hoʻopau o ka kumu o nā mea a pau ka hewa - i ka mana ia iho, hoikeia ma ka lehulehu kaiapili kauoha.

Ka hua'ōlelo "anarchy" haawi i kekahi mau manaʻo nui o ka poe mea he anarchist. Ka pākuʻina kau "em" ma ka olelo Helene, 'ōlelo hoʻopili like i Lūkini "ole" a "ole" a me ka "arhie"' o ia hoʻi ka mana. Pela o ke kanaka nana e hoole i ka hana no kenekulia ka hierarchical 'ole o ka hooponopono ana o ke kaiāulu, no ko ka ole mea pehea totalitarian pyramid ma luna o ka mea o ka Mō'ī, autocrat, hoʻomäinoino usurper a he pelekikena loa koho.

Ma ka ninau o ka poe mea he anarchist, loa kanaka i ulu mai ana ma ka Soviet au, maopopo koʻu manao i pane ia: "No ia mea, ke Papandopulo!" Kekahi hoomanao e pili ana i Nestor Makhno, kona kiʻi ua hanaʻia ma ke akamai o Socialist realism, ua ole emi he caricature. Ke wehewehe no keia pāʻewaʻewa i ka kumumanaʻo o ka anarchy a me ka ulu o ke kanaka noonoo ole.

A e like me ka loa mai ka Soviet mōʻaukala ho film, he moʻolelo e pili ana i nā hanana o ke Kanawai Kaua: Anarchistʻeleʻele hae me ka slogan "Anarchy - o ka makuwahine o ka mea!", E hooluhi ana i luna o ke kanaka marginalized. Aia He He ikaika Bolshevik commissar ka mea, ignoring i ka make māinoino, ma hope o ka manawa pōkole olelo Huipû ideological lanakila. ʻO wai lā ka mea he anarchist, he Communist i lohe a malama i kanaʻaoʻao? IeAUPIIe, IAa IO ka mea, ua puka liiiU, i ole e pili ana i ke kua'āina pilikino E pili, ahakanaka la a me ke hoohaihai aku ia i ka mea maikai na olelo hoopomaikai. Ma hope o ka Bolshevik kaʻakaʻa maila nā maka, hele koke i ka Red Army.

No ka mea, aʻo Kīwala'ō a pau o ka Pahuhopu i mai i loko o ka "Communist Manifesto" a ua hoikeia ma ka luku loa ana o ka moku'āina, nā Marxists ua kūkākūkāʻia e ia ia lŘlŘ like me ka hopena o ka Socialist kipi, a mahope kukulu. Ma nā hua'ōlelo, suppression i hoʻomākaukauʻia e make me ka hikiwawe e loaa ikaika ae la. 'O kēia ka papa likeʻole ma waena o ka Lūkini Marxists i loko o ka inoa o Trotsky, a Ulyanov (Lenin) mai ka bakunintsev, kropotkintsev paha Tolstoyans.

Like nui pilinaʻike manaʻo, Ua maheleia anarchism i loko o kekahi mau LIKE. Ka hapa nui o ia i ka io e pili ana i ke hoʻokele waiwai market, akā, kekahi mea ma kēia pukana o ka manao okoa. Ka ninau ana o ka poe i ka anarchist individualist, a pehea ia i kekahi, mai ka anarchist-syndicalist a anarchist-Communist, ka nui ana o ka laua ma waiwai.

Ma ka keia kahua i loko o na kia-Soviet aina kūlana o ka moku'āina o ua pinepine kaupalena 'ia kaʻohiʻohi auhau a me ka mālama i ka pono o ka ai-kapaia aliʻi me El. I ka wa e kaawale aku ai lōʻihi wī o ka lawelawe hoʻohiki, he poino ka lawelawe mālama ola, i ka hikiʻole a me ka unwillingness o na Aupuni no ka hoʻoponopono 'mau helu i māhele o ka heluna kanaka e kaumaha aku i ka hopohopo i ko lakou waiwai. Ma na ana, laila kekahi, laila kekahi kuokoa aupuni i hoʻokumu lākou kuikahi o anarchists. Kona Mamua ka ike o ka haʻahaʻa kālai'āina ka manaʻolana 'ia alakai ma kā lākou mau ana, akā, he mau helu o nā kākoʻo o ka anarchy manawa. E like me ka rula, ka mea e pili ana i anarchy like unrealistic, akā, nani moe.